Check Availability Reserve your table today!

Indianapolis

Change Location

3316 East 86th
Indianapolis, IN 46240 - Get Directions

  • (317) 268-8976
  • Hours [+]

    Dinner
    Monday - Saturday: 4:30 pm - 11:00 pm
    Sunday: 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm

    Lunch
    Monday - Friday: 11:00 am - 4:30 pm

    The Sure Thing
    Available Monday-Saturday | Three Courses $44
    Not For Private Events

    BAR
    Open Daily

Dinner

Starters

  • Cheesesteak Eggrolls

    Sweet & Spicy Chili Sauce & Honey Mustard

  • Seared Rare Ahi Tuna

    Pickled Ginger & Spicy Mustard Sauce

  • Crispy Shanghai Calamari

    Sweet Chili Glaze, Bean Sprouts, Cherry Peppers, Crushed Peanuts & Scallions

  • Lump Crabcake

    Cabbage Slaw & Roasted Garlic Tartar Sauce

  • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

    Cocktail Sauce & Lemon

  • Oysters On The Half Shell

    Cocktail Sauce, Horseradish & Saltines

Soups & Greens

  • French Onion Soup

    Gruyère, Swiss & Parmesan Cheese

  • Shrimp & Lobster Bisque

    Shrimp, Lobster, Sherry & Cream

  • Market Fresh Greens

    Cherry Tomatoes, Radish, Shaved Gruyère Cheese & Shallot-Dijon Vinaigrette

  • Iceberg Lettuce Wedge

    Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Blue Cheese Dressing

  • Caesar Salad

    Heart of Romaine, Shaved Parmesan, Toasted Crouton, Creamy Caesar Dressing & Anchovies

  • Add a Caesar, Wedge or Market Greens Salad to any entrée:

  • Steakhouse Salad

    Broiled Sliced Strip Steak, Deviled Egg, Mixed Greens, Avocado, Bacon, Parmesan, Blue Cheese & Lemon-Horseradish Dressing

  • Tableside BLT Salad

    Arugula, Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crisp Bacon, Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Vinaigrette

Sullivan's Bone-In Cuts

  • Long-Bone Berkshire Pork Chop 16oz

    Chipotle Peach Salsa

  • Bone-In Filet 14oz

  • Bone-In Ribeye Cowboy Cut 22oz

  • Wagyu Strip 16oz

  • Dry-Aged Long-Bone Ribeye 26oz

  • Roasted Rack of Lamb

    Grain Mustard-Rosemary Glaze

House-Cut Steaks

  • Filet Mignon

    8oz / 12 oz

  • New York Strip 12oz

  • Ribeye 16oz

Fresh Seafood & Chicken

  • 1 Pound Lobster Tail

    Simply Broiled, Carved Tableside & Served with Drawn Butter

  • Broiled Salmon Rockefeller

    Fresh Sautéed Spinach, Crabmeat, Béarnaise Sauce & Crisp Bacon

  • Seared Ahi Tuna

    Cajun Spice Rubbed, Cucumber Noodles & Spicy Mustard Sauce

  • Pan-Seared Sea Bass "Hong Kong Style"

    Baby Bok Choy & Sherry-Soy Glaze

  • Wild Caught King Crab Legs

    1lb, Steamed, Melted Butter & Lemon

  • Broiled Halibut T-Bone

    Citrus Basil Butter

  • Roasted Balsamic Chicken

    Wild Mushroom Couscous & Cipollini Onions

Enhance Your Entrée

  • Select a Complimentary Sauce of Your Choice

    Béarnaise, Bourbon Peppercorn, Bordelaise or Sullivan's Signature Steak Sauce

  • Oscar Style

    Lump Crab, Asparagus & Béarnaise

  • Signature Butters

    Cajun, Gorgonzola Garlic, Cabernet Goat Cheese

Side Dishes

  • Baked Potato

    Dressed Tableside

  • White Cheddar Au Gratin Potatoes

  • Three Cheese Mac

    Garlic Butter Crust

  • Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes

  • Wild Steakhouse Mushrooms

  • Fresh Broccoli

    Hollandaise Sauce

  • Grilled Asparagus

  • Shaved Brussels Sprouts

    Caramelized Onions & Smoked Bacon

  • Cream Style Spinach

  • Whole Roasted Cauliflower

    Caper Vinaigrette Drizzle

Desserts

  • Key Lime Pie

    Raspberry Sauce

  • Crème Brûlée

    Tahitian Vanilla Bean

  • New York-Style Cheesecake

    Graham Cracker Crust & Fresh Strawberries

  • Chocolate Meltdown

    Tableside Presentation. Hot Chocolate Sauce and Ganache Dome reveal a Flourless Chocolate Torte, Chocolate Mousse & Fresh Raspberries

  • Bananas Foster Bread Pudding

    Caramel Sauce & Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

LUNCH BEVERAGES

  • 50/50

    Freshly Brewed Iced Tea with Mint Lemonade

  • FRESH LEMONADE

    Original, Strawberry or Blueberry

STARTERS

  • CHEESESTEAK EGGROLLS

    Sweet & Spicy Chili Sauce & Honey Mustard

  • CRISPY SHANGHAI CALAMARI

    Sweet Chili Glaze, Bean Sprouts, Cherry Peppers, Crushed Peanuts & Scallions

  • JUMBO SHRIMP COCKTAIL

    Cocktail Sauce & Lemon

  • SEARED RARE AHI TUNA*

    Pickled Ginger & Spicy Mustard Sauce

  • SHRIMP & LOBSTER BISQUE

    Shrimp, Lobster, Sherry & Cream

  • FRENCH ONION SOUP

    Gruyère, Swiss & Parmesan Cheese

GREENS

  • Add a soup to any salad - $4

  • ICEBERG LETTUCE WEDGE

    Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Blue Cheese Dressing

  • MARKET FRESH GREENS

    Cherry Tomatoes, Radish, Shaved Gruyère Cheese & Shallot-Dijon Vinaigrette

  • CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD

    Crisp Romaine Leaves, Parmesan, Fresh Croutons & Creamy Caesar Dressing

  • STEAKHOUSE SALAD*

    Broiled Sliced Steak, Deviled Egg, Crunchy Cress, Avocado, Bacon, Parmesan, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Lemon-Horseradish Dressing

  • CHOPPED CHICKEN COBB

    Broiled Chicken Breast, Mixed Greens, Applewood Bacon, Eggs, Onions, Tomatoes, Avocado, Shredded White Cheddar, Almonds, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Dressing

  • CHICKEN KALE SALAD

    Crisp Apples, Dried Cranberries, Candied Pecans, Crumbled Goat Cheese & Apple Cider Vinaigrette

  • THAI BEEF SALAD*

    Broiled & Sliced Steak, Shaved Napa Cabbage, Arugula, Mangos, Chilled Noodles, Peanuts, Almonds, Tomatoes, Avocado & Ginger-Sesame Dressing

  • TABLESIDE BLT SALAD

    Arugula, Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crisp Bacon, Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Vinaigrette

THE MIXER

  • CHOOSE ONE FROM EACH COURSE - 19

  • STARTER

    Iceberg Lettuce Wedge, Caesar Salad, Market Fresh Greens, Shrimp & Lobster Bisque

  • ENTRÉE

    Blue Cheese Meatloaf, Roasted Balsamic Chicken, Simply Broiled Bay of Fundy Salmon*

  • SIDE

    Parmesan Fries, Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Thin Green Beans, Fresh Sautéed Spinach

SANDWICHES & MORE

  • Add a salad or soup - $4

  • AMERICAN BURGER*

    American Cheese, Shaved Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Bread & Butter Pickles, Brioche Bun & French Fries

  • CHICKEN BLT WRAP

    Smoked Bacon, Crisp Lettuce, Tomatoes, Sweet Basil Aioli & French Fries

  • SHAVED STEAK FRENCH DIP*

    Horseradish Sauce, Au Jus & French Fries

  • FISH TACOS

    Shredded Cabbage, Roasted Tomato Salsa, Cilantro, Spicy Mayo & Flour Tortillas

  • KOREAN BBQ BEEF TACOS

    Cabbage Slaw, Cilantro, Crushed Peanuts, Sriracha Aioli & Hoisin Sauce

LUNCH ENTREES

  • Our signature steaks are available upon request. Add a salad or soup - $4

  • FILET MIGNON* 6oz

    Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Thin Green Beans & Bordelaise. 8OZ FILET* ADD 10

  • SEARED AHI TUNA*

    Cajun Spice Rubbed, Cucumber Noodles & Spicy Mustard Sauce

  • FISH & CHIPS

    Hand Battered Haddock, Creamy Cabbage Slaw, French Fries & Tartar Sauce

  • TAVERN SLICED STEAK*

    Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Thin Green Beans & Bordelaise

  • ROASTED BALSAMIC CHICKEN

    Wild Mushroom Couscous & Cipollini Onions

SOUPS & GREENS

  • Shrimp & Lobster Bisque

  • Iceberg Lettuce Wedge

  • Market Fresh Greens

  • Caesar Salad

ENTREES

  • FILET MIGNON* 6OZ

    Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes & Bordelaise

  • SLICED NEW YORK STRIP* 8OZ

    Au Gratin Potatoes, Crispy Onion Straws & Bourbon Peppercorn Sauce

  • SIMPLY BROILED SALMON*

    Grilled Asparagus & Charred Lemon

  • --INDULGE--

    For just a little extra, elevate your Sure Thing with one of the following enhancements.

  • 8OZ FILET MIGNON*

  • 12OZ NEW YORK STRIP*

  • 12OZ FILET MIGNON*

  • 16OZ NEW YORK STRIP*

  • *Not Available for Private Events

DESSERTS

  • New York-Style Cheesecake

  • Key Lime Pie

  • Bananas Foster Bread Pudding

Bar Menu

  • STEAK FLATBREAD

    Blue Cheese, Cherry Peppers, Mozzarella & Balsamic Glazed Onions

  • AHI TUNA NACHOS

    Avocado Habañero Salsa, Crispy Wontons

  • SRIRACHA GLAZED SHRIMP

    Sweet & Spicy Chili Glaze, Sesame Seeds & Chives

  • CHEESESTEAK EGGROLLS

    Sweet & Spicy Chili Sauce & Honey Mustard

  • ROASTED FRENCH ONION MEATBALLS

    French Onion Sauce with Parmesan Gruyère Blend & Toasted Baguette.

  • LOADED POTATO TOTS

    Bacon, Chives, Cheddar Cheese & Truffle Aioli

  • BLUE CHEESE CHIPS

    Melted Blue Cheese & Scallions

  • BAR BURGER

    American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, B&B Pickles, Brioche Bun & French Fries

  • SESAME CHIVE SALMON

    Steamed Spinach, Sherry-Soy Glaze

  • TAVERN SLICED STEAK

    Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Thin Green Beans & Bordelaise

Check AvailabilityReserve your table online! visit us at sullivanssteakhouse.com